TY - JOUR
T1 - Prioritisation of operations improvement projects in the European manufacturing industry
AU - Kirkham, Louis
AU - Garza-Reyes, Jose Arturo
AU - Kumar, Vikas
AU - Antony, Jiju
N1 - Funding Information:
IAEA (2006) suggests that the deployment of an improvement approach that strongly emphasises project prioritisation is likely to increase the chance of success of operations improvement projects. One of these improvement approaches is Six Sigma. The fundamentals of Six Sigma are to create a well-structured, methodical and project-based approach towards process improvement (Van Iwaarden et al. 2008; Garza-Reyes et al. 2014). Thus, since Six Sigma is a project driven methodology, it emphasises the prioritisation of improvement projects to maximise financial benefits (Ingle and Roe 2001; Coronado and Antony 2002). Antony (2006) states that the correct selection and prioritisation of projects is a key critical success factor in a Six Sigma programme, which suggests that organisations adopting this improvement approach are likely to use objective project prioritisation methods. This is supported by the results of a survey carried out by Bañuelas et al. (2006), which targeted large UK organisations implementing Six Sigma. The study found that almost all Six Sigma organisations in the study use at least one objective method for project prioritisation, with the most common being CBA and Pareto analysis, both of which are tools of Six Sigma (Sharma and Chetiya 2010).
PY - 2014/9/17
Y1 - 2014/9/17
N2 - To improve their competitive ability, organisations are turning towards implementing improvements into their operations and processes. Whilst operations improvement projects are often identified with relative ease, resource constraints limit the ability of organisations to conduct them simultaneously. This paper supports the limited empirical research on prioritisation of improvement initiatives by investigating how European manufacturing organisations conduct this activity. To do this, four hypotheses and two research questions were formulated and tested using a combination of descriptive statistics and two proportion T-tests, while data was collected through a survey questionnaire responded by 203 organisations. The results highlight the importance of objectively prioritising improvement projects and establish that the adoption of this method increases through the implementation of improvement methodologies, especially those that stipulate the use of objective methods towards project prioritisation. In this way, Six Sigma is defined as the most influential improvement methodology for supporting the use of objective prioritisation approaches. The paper also identifies the reasons as to why organisations adopt subjective over objective prioritisation methods, and the most common approaches used by large organisations and small and medium enterprises. This research provides organisations, and their managers, with a better understanding of the different factors that affect this key aspect of operations improvement projects.
AB - To improve their competitive ability, organisations are turning towards implementing improvements into their operations and processes. Whilst operations improvement projects are often identified with relative ease, resource constraints limit the ability of organisations to conduct them simultaneously. This paper supports the limited empirical research on prioritisation of improvement initiatives by investigating how European manufacturing organisations conduct this activity. To do this, four hypotheses and two research questions were formulated and tested using a combination of descriptive statistics and two proportion T-tests, while data was collected through a survey questionnaire responded by 203 organisations. The results highlight the importance of objectively prioritising improvement projects and establish that the adoption of this method increases through the implementation of improvement methodologies, especially those that stipulate the use of objective methods towards project prioritisation. In this way, Six Sigma is defined as the most influential improvement methodology for supporting the use of objective prioritisation approaches. The paper also identifies the reasons as to why organisations adopt subjective over objective prioritisation methods, and the most common approaches used by large organisations and small and medium enterprises. This research provides organisations, and their managers, with a better understanding of the different factors that affect this key aspect of operations improvement projects.
KW - improvements prioritisation
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84906318853&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1080/00207543.2014.903345
DO - 10.1080/00207543.2014.903345
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:84906318853
SN - 0020-7543
VL - 52
SP - 5323
EP - 5345
JO - International Journal of Production Research
JF - International Journal of Production Research
IS - 18
ER -